Acupuncture vs Dry Needling - aren’t they the same?

If I had a dollar for every time I’ve been asked the following question, I’d be a retired millionaire, lying on a desert island somewhere exotic, being brought cocktails whilst being treated to a foot massage 💰🏝️🍹…but I digress! 

So, what is this commonest question, I hear you ask? It is “What is the difference between Acupuncture and Dry Needling?”, and to be honest, it’s a great question!  From a patient’s perspective, the same type of thin, stainless steel needles are used, thus both treatment modalities can appear almost identical. So, as a qualified practitioner in both methods, I’ll try and demystify these essentially quite different techniques.

First, lets start with Dry Needling:

  • Developed in the 1940’s but rose in popularity in the 1980’s, so a fairly new modality

  • Based on a Western medical paradigm

  • Targets ‘trigger points’ or tight bands of muscle, which may be causing pain

  • Limited to muscular pain or discomfort

  •  May elicit a ‘twitch response’, which prompts relaxation in the affected muscle group

  •  Needles commonly retained for a few minutes

  • Provides symptomatic relief only

  •  Qualifications can be attained in 24 – 72 hours, via short courses

  •  Performed by Remedial Massage Therapists, Myotherapists, Physiotherapists & Osteopaths

  •  No formal registration requirements currently in place

In comparison, Acupuncture:

  • Is an integral part of Chinese Medicine treatment since 100BCE (yep, 1000’s of years!)

  • Based on Eastern medical paradigm

  • Needles are placed strategically along selected acupuncture channels

  • Works on redressing imbalances within the body, to promote self-healing

  • Targets the root cause of ‘dis-ease’

  • Used to treat a wide range of conditions

  • Needles can be retained from 10-40 minutes, allowing time for an ‘acu-nap’

  • Only qualified Doctors of Chinese Medicine may perform acupuncture

  • Qualifications take 4+ years to attain

  • AHPRA registration is required to perform acupuncture

So, as you can see, both treatments have their value, it just depends on your requirements as a patient.  Whether you’re looking for relief from a muscular injury or for more of a systemic condition, needles might just be your answer. 

If I’ve piqued your interest in either or both of these modalities, get in touch and give them a try!

Yours in good health,

Nikki

To experience these needling techniques in person, book an appointment here.

Next
Next

Ginger tea anyone?